Well Meaning Fiction (Compact Disc)

Minnesota winters can be cause for reflection, self-analysis and praying for spring. They’ve also played muse to some great songs. The Mary Tyler Moore theme, sure, but I was mostly thinking of “Skyway” by the Replacements. Another in that vein is “Overnight On Nicolet,” from the debut album by Mainstay, Well Meaning Fiction.

“Must have been that winter cold,” the song begins, before describing the rather joyless life that has befallen the singer/ songwriter, Justin Anderson, who’s seeking a return to the faith of his youth, his first love in Christ. Whether it’s the winter’s influence or the Scandinavian heritage of many of the area’s natives, there is a sternness, a seriousness that underlies these unfailingly appealing, if often predictable, alternative pop songs.

Veteran producer Aaron Sprinkle (Starflyer 59, Falling Up) adds a nostalgic mid-’90s tone (think Vervepipe’s hit, “The Freshman”) with just the right layers of guitars and synth washes to create a sterling support for Anderson’s effecting vocals. Joined in this three-piece by Ryan DeYounge and Dan Ostebo, Mainstay will need support producing these lush musical environs live.

For his part, Anderson has strong opinions and doesn’t hesitate to say what’s on his mind, writing from time to time of a “they” with whom he disagrees. Of course, tracks like “These Pages,” which invite God’s Spirit to lead us through the Scriptures, or “Yesterday,” which condemns living in the past, will connect across the board. But some Christians might wonder if his reference to those who’ve dumbed down the gospel message in the title track is a judgement of them.

Brian Q. Newcomb

Review Provided by CCMmagazine.com